
Take measles. If a child suddenly develops signs and symptoms of measles she goes to the Doctor. Why, because she is deathly ill. Measles is a reportable disease. A reportable disease mandates that the Dr. report its occurrence to the local health department. The local health department reports it to the state health department, who in turns reports it to the CDC. In the case of measles, one case is considered an outbreak. What is an outbreak? An outbreak occurs when by definition it happens. This means that the public health machine on the local, state and federal level swings into action. Ok, what next? This is what must be determined.
1. Who has the confirmed case of the disease and who is suspected of having it.
2. Has that person been immunized if an immunization is available?
3. Who has this person been in contact with?
4. Start with family members.
5. Are these people immunized? If not, offer immunization or prophylactic medicine IF there is one.
6. Is anyone starting to show signs and symptoms of the illness?
7. If so, whom have each of these people been in contact?
8. Follow up with each and every contact to see if they have been immunized. If not, offer immunization and prophylaxis. This continues until a point is reached that no one is showing signs or symptoms of the illness.
Also, with each person it must be determined if they have traveled, where, by what mode of transportation, and whom each of these "contacts" could have possibly been in contact.Disease surveillance and contact investigation is the only way we have to stop a communicable disease in its tracks. This is a heck of a lot of work for just a few people to do. Is it easier to just close a school and prevent additional contacts....Yes.
Any new virus which has the potential to kill, or any old contagious illness which causes death or disability is enough to get this cycle going. We know that measles kills people and can leave them permanently disabled. It is known that H1N1 kills, but we have no idea how fast or if it can cause permanent disability. Please give public health, the CDC, and the WHO a break. They are working overtime with an unknown entity.
They are working to protect the entire population of the world. Do you want that job?
Remember the horror this county felt when it was discovered that Rubella, the mild 3-day German measles left the human unborn fetus with horrible birth defects? I remember and guess what? I was pregnant with my first baby and there was no preventable vaccine. Did I worry, well yea...I was in nurses training taking care of sick children.
During 1964 and 1965 a rubella epidemic in the United States caused an estimated 12.5million cases of rubella and 20,000 cases of congenital rubella syndrome (CRS) which led to more than 11,600 babies born deaf, 11,250 fetal deaths, 2,100 neonatal deaths, 3,580 babies born blind and 1,800 babies born mentally challenged.
My hope is that H1N1 will turn out to be less potent. But, in the mean time, is it better to have too much information than not enough? Is it better to be too cautious?
Yes!